• A
  • A
  • A
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
Regular version of the site

Scientists Examine Neurobiology of Pragmatic Reasoning

Scientists Examine Neurobiology of Pragmatic Reasoning

© iStock

An international team including scientists from HSE University has investigated the brain's ability to comprehend hidden meanings in spoken messages. Using fMRI, the researchers found that unambiguous meanings activate brain regions involved in decision-making, whereas processing complex and ambiguous utterances engages regions responsible for analysing context and the speaker's intentions. The more complex the task, the greater the interaction between these regions, enabling the brain to decipher the meaning. The study has been published in NeuroImage.

Everyone has likely encountered a situation where the words spoken by their conversation partner did not align with their intended message. We can understand innuendos, irony, and sarcasm, even when the spoken words formally convey the opposite meaning. In cognitive science, this process is known as pragmatic reasoning—the ability to infer meaning from context, even when it is not explicitly expressed.

An international team of scientists conducted a study to uncover how the brain processes such situations. The study participants played a reference game, an experimental method used to investigate how people interpret ambiguous messages. In each trial, participants saw four expressible features and three monsters on the screen—a potato monster, an eggplant monster, and a pear monster. Each monster wore an accessory: a blue hat, a red hat, or a yellow scarf. The speaker sent a message highlighted by a yellow rectangle, such as 'red hat.' Participants had to determine which character was implied, but the clue was not always unambiguous, and the correct answer depended on the context. The experiment had three levels of complexity: simple, complex, and unambiguous, with the latter serving as the baseline condition. There were a total of 96 trials, with 32 trials for each level.

To identify which regions of the brain are involved in the interpretation process, the scientists recorded the participants' brain activity using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). This neuroimaging method makes it possible to study brain activity in real time. The authors of the paper also developed six computer models to characterise participants' behaviour and the strategies they use to interpret the information.

Figure 1. C–E. Examples of tasks with three levels of complexity: simple, complex, and unambiguous
©Shanshan Zhen, Mario Martinez-Saito, Rongjun Yu, Beyond what was said: Neural computations underlying pragmatic reasoning in referential communication, NeuroImage, Volume 306, 2025, 121022, ISSN 1053-8119, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2025.121022.

Their findings reveal that when a participant quickly understood the intended meaning of a phrase and was confident in their answer, the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC), involved in decision-making, and the ventral striatum (VS), associated with the feeling of having made the right choice, were active.

However, when the meaning of an utterance was ambiguous, the brain activated other regions: the dorsomedial prefrontal cortex (dmPFC), which analyses the interlocutor's intentions and helps make sense of complex situations; the anterior insula (AI), which responds to uncertainty and tension by contributing to the generation of emotions; and the inferior frontal gyrus (IFG), responsible for language processing. The more complex the task, the more actively these regions interacted, helping the brain correctly interpret the meaning.

The researchers also found that the ability to understand others' thoughts and emotions contributed to successful performance. Participants who performed better exhibited stronger functional connectivity between the prefrontal cortex and the anterior insular cortex, indicating greater flexibility in their reasoning. Previously, pragmatic reasoning was studied within the framework of general models that involve common cognitive mechanisms. However, this study reveals that interpretation strategies can differ among individuals.

'Language comprehension is not just a matter of intelligence or memory. Our brain uses a complex system that integrates language, social cognition, and context analysis,' explains Mario Martinez-Saito, Research Fellow at the HSE International Laboratory of Social Neurobiology. 'The results obtained could also have practical applications. Perhaps, thanks to such research, your voice assistant will finally be able to distinguish between sincere praise and sarcasm.'

See also:

Group and Shuffle: Researchers at HSE University and AIRI Accelerate Neural Network Fine-Tuning

Researchers at HSE University and the AIRI Institute have proposed a method for quickly fine-tuning neural networks. Their approach involves processing data in groups and then optimally shuffling these groups to improve their interactions. The method outperforms alternatives in image generation and analysis, as well as in fine-tuning text models, all while requiring less memory and training time. The results have been presented at the NeurIPS 2024 Conference.

When Thoughts Become Movement: How Brain–Computer Interfaces Are Transforming Medicine and Daily Life

At the dawn of the 21st century, humans are increasingly becoming not just observers, but active participants in the technological revolution. Among the breakthroughs with the potential to change the lives of millions, brain–computer interfaces (BCIs)—systems that connect the brain to external devices—hold a special place. These technologies were the focal point of the spring International School ‘A New Generation of Neurointerfaces,’ which took place at HSE University.

New Clustering Method Simplifies Analysis of Large Data Sets

Researchers from HSE University and the Institute of Control Sciences of the Russian Academy of Sciences have proposed a new method of data analysis: tunnel clustering. It allows for the rapid identification of groups of similar objects and requires fewer computational resources than traditional methods. Depending on the data configuration, the algorithm can operate dozens of times faster than its counterparts. Thestudy was published in the journal Doklady Rossijskoj Akademii Nauk. Mathematika, Informatika, Processy Upravlenia.

Researchers from HSE University in Perm Teach AI to Analyse Figure Skating

Researchers from HSE University in Perm have developed NeuroSkate, a neural network that identifies the movements of skaters on video and determines the correctness of the elements performed. The algorithm has already demonstrated success with the basic elements, and further development of the model will improve its accuracy in identifying complex jumps. 

Script Differences Hinder Language Switching in Bilinguals

Researchers at the HSE Centre for Language and Brain used eye-tracking to examine how bilinguals switch between languages in response to context shifts. Script differences were found to slow down this process. When letters appear unfamiliar—such as the Latin alphabet in a Russian-language text—the brain does not immediately switch to the other language, even when the person is aware they are in a bilingual setting. The article has been published in Bilingualism: Language and Cognition.

HSE Experts Highlight Factors Influencing EV Market Growth

According to estimates from HSE University, Moscow leads in the number of charging stations for electric vehicles in Russia, while Nizhny Novgorod ranks first in terms of charging station coverage, with 11.23 electric vehicles per charging station, compared to 14.41 in Moscow. The lack of charging infrastructure is one of the key factors limiting the growth of the electric vehicle market. This is stated in the study titled ‘Socio-Economic Aspects of Introducing Electric Vehicles in Commercial Transportation’ conducted by experts from the Institute of Transport Economics and Transport Policy Studies at HSE University.

Machine Learning Links Two New Genes to Ischemic Stroke

A team of scientists from HSE University and the Kurchatov Institute used machine learning methods to investigate genetic predisposition to stroke. Their analysis of the genomes of over 5,000 people identified 131 genes linked to the risk of ischemic stroke. For two of these genes, the association was found for the first time. The paper has been published in PeerJ Computer Science.

First Digital Adult Reading Test Available on RuStore

HSE University's Centre for Language and Brain has developed the first standardised tool for assessing Russian reading skills in adults—the LexiMetr-A test. The test is now available digitally on the RuStore platform. This application allows for a quick and effective diagnosis of reading disorders, including dyslexia, in people aged 18 and older.

Low-Carbon Exports Reduce CO2 Emissions

Researchers at the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences and the Federal Research Centre of Coal and Coal Chemistry have found that exporting low-carbon goods contributes to a better environment in Russian regions and helps them reduce greenhouse gas emissions. The study results have been published in R-Economy.

Russian Scientists Assess Dangers of Internal Waves During Underwater Volcanic Eruptions

Mathematicians at HSE University in Nizhny Novgorod and the A.V. Gaponov-Grekhov Institute of Applied Physics of the Russian Academy of Sciences studied internal waves generated in the ocean after the explosive eruption of an underwater volcano. The researchers calculated how the waves vary depending on ocean depth and the radius of the explosion source. It turns out that the strongest wave in the first group does not arrive immediately, but after a significant delay. This data can help predict the consequences of eruptions and enable advance preparation for potential threats. The article has been published in Natural Hazards. The research was carried out with support from the Russian Science Foundation (link in Russian).